Lisa Green (lisagailgreen) wrote in enchantedinkpot,
Lisa Green
lisagailgreen
enchantedinkpot

What IS My Novel?

Here at the Enchanted Inkpot we love fantasy in all forms. And oh how many different forms there are! I’ve seen debates on Twitter on this topic. I’ve seen new (and not so new) writers ask the question, "what do I call my manuscript?" Sometimes these sub-genres can become a bit tangled, making it difficult to tell where one starts and another begins. So how do we classify these concepts? I started by researching the answers online, and guess what? There was no “one” perfect answer. Surprise, surprise! After discussing with some fellow Inkies, I’ve given it my best attempt.

•High Fantasy - Let’s start with an easy one, shall we? High fantasy refers to a completely unique world with its own rules. Think LORD OF THE RINGS, GRACELING, and MISTWOOD.

•Reality-Based Fantasy (aka Contemporary Fantasy and Low Fantasy)- Ah here we go. Reality-based fantasy refers to a story grounded in the “real” world with magical elements interwoven as though they exist naturally. Examples would include HARRY POTTER, THE GRAVEYARD BOOK, THE LIGHTENING THIEF and SMALL PERSONS WITH WINGS.

•Magical Realism – Wait – what’s the difference between Magical Realism and Reality-Based Fantasy? Good question. In Magical Realism the fantastic elements are generally accepted as part of the world as opposed to being hidden. Examples of this would be THE KEEPER, THE MERMAID’S MIRROR, SAVVY, and TORTILLA SUN.

•Urban Fantasy – Fantasy that exists in a modern, urban setting. The difference between this and Magical Realism? Think of it this way – if your book takes place in the remote island of Hapakulanani, or centuries prior around Stonehenge, it probably doesn’t belong in this category. What does? Books like TITHE and WHITE CAT, as well as CITY OF BONES and WICKED LOVELY.

•Historical Fantasy – Fantasy elements in a historical setting. Books like BEWITCHING SEASON and BETRAYING SEASON, and A GREAT AND TERRIBLE BEAUTY.

•Paranormal – If you know me, you probably know that this category has a special place in my heart. Yep, we’re talking Vampires, werewolves, and other fantastic creatures that exist in our own world. And not all paranormals are romances. I would classify books like CRUSADE, SHIVER, and HUSH HUSH as paranormal.

Those are the sub-genres I hear of the most. What do you think? Have I missed something? Miscategorized something? Let me know! What I find most interesting about this topic is the apparent subjective nature of these categories. That so many people disagree on the lines between them is a testament to the complex nature of fantasy.
Tags: totw
Subscribe

  • TOTW: Science Fiction vs Fantasy

    The Enchanted Inkpot was founded to provide a place for authors and readers to talk about fantasy-- especially traditional fantasy-- written for…

  • World Fantasy Con Wrap Up!

    Last Thursday, over 800 authors, illustrators, editors, booksellers and fans descended on the Town and Country Hotel and Convention Centre in San…

  • TOTW: Mermaids!

    For many people, the quintessential mermaid is Ariel of The Little Mermaid. For me, it’s the siren in The Mermaid Summer by Mollie Hunter…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for members only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 30 comments

  • TOTW: Science Fiction vs Fantasy

    The Enchanted Inkpot was founded to provide a place for authors and readers to talk about fantasy-- especially traditional fantasy-- written for…

  • World Fantasy Con Wrap Up!

    Last Thursday, over 800 authors, illustrators, editors, booksellers and fans descended on the Town and Country Hotel and Convention Centre in San…

  • TOTW: Mermaids!

    For many people, the quintessential mermaid is Ariel of The Little Mermaid. For me, it’s the siren in The Mermaid Summer by Mollie Hunter…